✕ ✕
Turning tips into memories
Login
Signup

You have reached the limit of free articles.


To enjoy unlimited access to Culture Whisper sign up for FREE.
Find out more about Culture Whisper

Please fix the following input errors:

  • dummy

Each week, we send newsletters and communication featuring articles, our latest tickets invitations, and exclusive offers.

Occasional information about discounts, special offers and promotions.


OR
LOG IN

OR
  • LOG IN WITH FACEBOOK

Thanks for signing up to Culture Whisper.
Please check your inbox for a confirmation email and click the link to verify your account.



EXPLORE CULTURE WHISPER
✕ ✕
Turning tips into memories
Login
Signup

Please fix the following input errors:

  • dummy
Forgot your username or password?
Don't have an account? Sign Up

OR
  • LOG IN WITH FACEBOOK

If you click «Log in with Facebook» and are not a Culture Whisper user, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and to our Privacy Policy, which includes our Cookie Use

Support Us Login
  • Home
  • Going Out
    • Things to do
    • Food & Drink
    • Theatre
    • Visual Arts
    • Cinema
    • Kids
    • Festival
    • Gigs
    • Dance
    • Classical Music
    • Opera
    • Immersive
    • Talks
  • Staying In
    • TV
    • Books
    • Cook
    • Podcast
    • Design
    • Netflix
  • Life & Style
    • Beauty
    • Fashion
    • Gifting
    • Wellbeing
    • Lifestyle
    • Shopping
    • Jewellery
  • Explore
  • Shopping
  • CW SHOPS
  • Support Us
  • Get Started
  • Tickets
  • CW SHOPS
Get the Best of London Life, Culture and Style
By entering my email I agree to the CultureWhisper Privacy Policy (we won`t share data & you can unsubscribe anytime).
Cinema

Silence film review ★★★★★

01 Jan 17 – 01 Mar 17, Times vary

Andrew Garfield, Liam Neeson, and Adam Driver star in the new epic drama directed by Martin Scorsese. Silence has conviction, but feels like it's preaching to the choir

By CW Contributor on 20/12/2016

1 CW reader is interested
Liam Neeson – Silence, Martin Scorsese new film
Liam Neeson – Silence, Martin Scorsese new film
Silence film review 3 Silence film review Matthew Robinson
Is Silence penance for The Wolf of Wall Street?


The question has to be asked because the two films differ so much subject and intention while differing so little in method and outcome. Martin Scorsese’s last film – the 2013 biopic of corrupt stockbroker Jordan Belfort – was an unapologetic celebration of hedonistic individualism, and its intention was pure cinematic pleasure; Silence – the story of a Portuguese Catholic priest acting as a missionary in 17th Century Japan – is a religious appreciation of transcendental selflessness, and its apparent intention is cinematic mortification. (Marty asks: how much suffering can a man take in the name of his faith? But also: how long can an audience sit still when not much is happening onscreen?)



The films represent are opposites – profanity and piety, wolf and lamb ­­– but onIy as opposing sides to the same heavy coin. Both show the ‘journey’ of a young man who ends up falsely repentant, only superficially renouncing his true vocation while remaining resistant to inner change. To doubt is to capitulate. These are films with their minds already made up.


Sebastião Rodrigues (Andrew Garfield) and Francisco Garrpe (Adam Driver), two Portuguese Catholic priests, are deeply concerned by the rumour that Father Cristóvão Ferreira (Liam Neeson) has apostatised, and now lives in collusion with the godless Japanese whom he went over to convert. Through sheer earnestness they browbeat their superior (Ciarán Hinds) into letting them make the arduous journey to Japan, where they plan to redress any potential sacrilegious influence and find out what has happened to Ferreira.



Andrew Garfield in Silence


Their arrival and adjustment constitutes the first act, which is the best part of Silence. Hiding out in the mist-shrouded coastal village, secretly performing rites for the cowering populace and witnessing their persecution by government agents, Rodrigues and Garrpe are damp and wild-eyed, blanched by culture shock and fervid with the chance to properly spread the Word. Then circumstance leads them to go their separate ways, and this is where Scorsese’s film becomes less interesting when it needed to become more interesting.


Part of the problem is that the narrative follows Garfield’s character rather than Driver’s. Garfield is a perfectly competent actor, underrated as a comic one but overrated as a dramatic one: his performance in Silence squeezes out pathos in the same way as he did in The Social Network (acting disbelievingly betrayed) and Never Let Me Go (disbelievingly disabused). His character never really expresses internal conflict any more convincingly than Leonardo DiCaprio’s did in Wolf.


At one point the two priests cross paths again, although only at a distance. It’s hard to see Adam Driver’s hunched skeletal frame on the horizon and not wish that the cameras had followed him instead. He practically played a monk in Paterson, and gave that film a subtlety that Silence lacks.

by Matthew Robinson

What Silence film review
Where Various Locations | MAP
Nearest tube Leicester Square (underground)
When 01 Jan 17 – 01 Mar 17, Times vary
Price £determined by cinema
Website Click here for more details



Most popular

Things to do in London this weekend: 12 - 14 August
Things to do in London this weekend: 12 - 14 August
London's loveliest indoor swimming pools
London swimming pools you can visit without membership
London Theatre Guide: best plays on now in London (Photograph: Peter Lewicki)
London Theatre Guide: best plays on now in London, 2022

Editor's Picks


  • 1. BEST DRAMA ON TV

    If you thought the best of Nordic noir was over, we’ve got a surprise for you

    2. THE PLANET EARTH II AWARDS

    We rate the best animals from David Attenborough’s inspiring nature documentary

    3. FILMS YOU MISSED THIS YEAR

    When someone asks you about the best thing you saw this year, don’t say ‘Batman v. Superman’

    4. STOP KILLING ALL THE WOMEN!

    We’ve seen one too many ‘sexy psychopath’ series on TV, and we’ve had enough

What members say

    A relentless experience that unravels the complex riddles of religion, faith, power and politics.

    Alice Godwin

Sign up to CW’s newsletter
By entering my email I agree to the CultureWhisper Privacy Policy (we won`t share data & you can unsubscribe anytime).
1

Cinema

Drama

Adam Driver

Liam Neeson

Andrew Garfield

Martin Scorsese

You might like

  • Owen Suskind – Life, Animated

    Life, Animated film review ★★★★★

  • The Pass film review

    The Pass film review ★★★★★

  • The Ardennes film

    The Ardennes film review ★★★★★

  • Passengers film review [STAR:2]

    Passengers film review ★★★★★



  • The Culture Whisper team
  • Support Us
  • Tickets
  • Contact us
  • Press
  • FAQ
  • Privacy
  • Terms and conditions
  • Cookies
  • Discover
  • Venues
  • Restaurants
  • Stations
  • Boroughs
Sign up to CW’s newsletter
By entering my email I agree to the CultureWhisper Privacy Policy (we won`t share data & you can unsubscribe anytime).
×