The case arose when Dr Lipstadt accused an infamous
Holocaust-denier, David Irving, of deliberately distorting historical truth to
further his anti-Semitic ideology. He sued for defamation, and rather than
settle quietly she took it to the courts for a year-long legal battle to clear
her name – tarnishing his reputation in the process.
As a film dramatising a conflict of misinformation, Denial succeeds in refraining from
dramatising it too much. While most of the actual dialogue is invented, the
courtroom scenes are recreated verbatim, lending legitimacy to proceedings that
surprise with their dramatic force. As the legal team is assembled and matters
get underway, playwright and screenwriter David Hare (The Reader, The Hours) pieces
together an admirably accurate portrait of the parties involved.
Lipstadt's head solicitor is quietly captured by Sherlock's Andrew Scott, who does more
in a nod than his co-stars achieve over the course of the two-hour film. Tom
Wilkinson appears as the pensive QC representing Lipstadt in court, while Timothy
Spall's antagonist expertly treads the line between distasteful rhetoric and heartfelt
Timothy Spall in Denial
Rachel Weisz proves a steady hand in anchoring the film's
action, but symbolises the bland mode of operation at the heart of this
hesitant, often dry biopic. Tears and declamations are often unconvincing,
while the careful sensitivity around the film's subject prevents any real
tension building, stifling dramatic encounters under its kid gloves.
Director Mick Jackson waxes lyrical about the film's
camerawork, saying a film concerned with truth "should have a luminous
quality". Most scenes are shot as if in natural light, giving even the
tersest moments a steady documentary feel, forgoing the urgency expected from a
high-stakes courtroom battle.
Given its weighty subject matter, and the importance of respectfully navigating the historical horrors hanging over the action, Denial proves a perfectly functional vehicle for its purpose. It will satisfy your curiosity, if not your appetite.
|What||Denial film review|
|Where||Various Locations | MAP|
|Nearest tube||Leicester Square (underground)|
27 Jan 17 – 27 Mar 17, Times vary
|Price||£determined by cinema|
|Website||Click here for more details|